Which scenario exemplifies constructive criticism?

Constructive criticism involves providing feedback that is aimed at helping someone improve rather than just pointing out flaws. This means not only identifying areas that need work but also suggesting specific improvements or alternatives to address those issues. When observations are shared along with practical recommendations, it empowers the recipient to enhance their skills or change their approach.

In the scenario where improvements are suggested based on observations, the feedback is likely to be well-received because it provides a clear path forward. This approach fosters a supportive environment where learners can grow, as they can see how to implement the advice given. Constructive criticism helps individuals understand their performance while motivating them to strive for better outcomes through actionable steps.

The other scenarios do not fulfill the criteria for constructive criticism, as they either lack solutions, actionable advice, or adequate reasoning to support the feedback, thereby failing to encourage development effectively.